Are Staten Island Homeowners Being Taxed Unfairly Compared to Wealthier NYC Neighborhoods?

Why Staten Island Gets the Short End of the Stick

“Why are Staten Island homeowners often paying more in taxes than wealthier NYC neighborhoods? It’s not what you think.”

The answer lies in how New York City calculates property taxes. Staten Island families—especially owners of one- and two-family homes—are often assessed at higher effective tax rates than owners of multimillion-dollar condos or brownstones in Manhattan and Brooklyn.

Luxury properties in wealthy neighborhoods are frequently undervalued on the city’s tax rolls, keeping their tax bills artificially low. The result? Staten Island homeowners are left carrying more of the burden, despite their homes being worth a fraction of those high-end properties.

How This Impacts Staten Island Families

1. Housing Costs: Higher effective property taxes drive up monthly costs for homeowners and buyers alike.

2. Buyer Hesitation: Potential buyers may hesitate when comparing Staten Island’s property tax bills to what’s owed on luxury properties elsewhere in the city.

3. Equity Concerns: Sellers may not see the full benefit of their home’s appreciation if tax burdens make the property less attractive.

Why This Matters in the Market

Property taxes aren’t just a line item—they shape affordability and influence demand. For Staten Island homeowners, the disparity in NYC’s tax system means middle-class families are subsidizing the tax breaks enjoyed by the wealthiest property owners elsewhere.

If you’re thinking of selling, taxes can affect buyer demand and your net proceeds. If you’re buying, understanding what property taxes mean for your monthly budget is just as critical as the purchase price itself.

Bottom Line

Yes—Staten Island homeowners are often paying more in property taxes than luxury property owners in other boroughs. The system is unbalanced, and it directly impacts affordability, buyer behavior, and seller outcomes here on the Island.

What This Means for You

At Your Home Sold Guaranteed Realty Advisors LLC, we help Staten Island buyers and sellers understand every part of the process—including how property taxes affect their bottom line.

📞 Call 718-608-4892 today for a personalized market and property tax impact review.

Multiple cash offers on your home in minutes with at least one at

100% of market value.  

Call 718-608-4892 to receive your multiple cash offers today.

Your Home Sold Guaranteed or We'll Buy It!*