Hot take: After the recent rule changes, should sellers still pay buyer-agent fees?

It’s one of the biggest debates in the Staten Island and Brooklyn real estate market right now.

The Case Against Offering Buyer-Agent Compensation

Some argue that sellers shouldn’t offer compensation at all. The logic is simple—if buyers have their own agents, they can pay for their own representation. In theory, this could save the seller thousands in commission.

The Case For Offering Buyer-Agent Compensation

Others say the opposite—strategically offering compensation can actually work in your favor. Here’s why:

• Wider Buyer Pool – Many buyers expect their agent to be paid from the seller’s side, and skipping this could deter them from even scheduling a showing.

• Faster Time-to-Contract – More agents actively promoting your property means more exposure, more offers, and often a quicker sale.

Our Approach at Your Home Sold Guaranteed Realty Advisors, LLC

In practice, it’s deal-by-deal and market-by-market. That’s why we model both scenarios for every listing before launch:

1. With Buyer-Agent Compensation – You see the potential for faster sales and higher offer volume.

2. Without Buyer-Agent Compensation – You see exactly how much you could save in commission.

We give you a side-by-side net sheet so you can make the choice that’s best for your goals—before your home even hits the market.

Bottom Line for Staten Island & Brooklyn Sellers

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. It’s about knowing your market conditions, weighing your options, and making a decision that maximizes your net proceeds.

📩 Want the numbers?
Comment your stance below — then DM “NET SHEET” or call 718-608-4892 to get your side-by-side breakdown with and without buyer-agent compensation for your home.