Thinking about buying or selling a home in Tottenville, Staten Island, in 2025?

by Hal Blake

You're in the right place. Tottenville, known for its charming Victorian homes and waterfront views, offers unique opportunities for both buyers and sellers. Let's dive into what makes this neighborhood stand out and what you should consider in today's market.

Understanding Tottenville's Real Estate Landscape

A Neighborhood with Character

Tottenville is Staten Island's southernmost neighborhood, bordered by water on three sides. Its rich history, tree-lined streets, and tight-knit community make it a desirable place to live. The area boasts a mix of architectural styles, from historic homes to modern constructions, catering to diverse tastes.

Current Market Trends

As of April 2025, the median listing price in Tottenville is around $799,000, with homes selling for a median price of $790,000. This represents a slight decrease from the previous year, indicating a more balanced market.

For Buyers: Making the Right Move

Opportunities in a Balanced Market

The current market conditions in Tottenville present opportunities for buyers. With prices stabilizing, you have the chance to negotiate and find a home that fits your needs and budget.

What to Look For

Location: Proximity to schools, parks, and transportation can impact your daily life and property value.
Home Condition: Consider the age of the home and any necessary renovations.
Future Developments: Be aware of any planned developments that might affect the neighborhood's dynamics.

Personal Insight

When I was house hunting in Tottenville, I prioritized being close to the Staten Island Railway for an easy commute. I found a charming colonial just a short walk from the station, which made daily travel a breeze.

For Sellers: Standing Out in the Market

Preparing Your Home

To attract buyers, ensure your home is in top condition. Simple updates like fresh paint, landscaping, and minor repairs can make a significant difference.

Pricing Strategically

Setting the right price is crucial. Overpricing can deter buyers, while underpricing might lead to a quicker sale but less profit. Consult with a local real estate agent to determine a competitive price based on recent sales.

Personal Experience

I helped a friend sell their Tottenville home last year. By staging the home and highlighting its unique features, we attracted multiple offers and sold above the asking price.

Navigating the Process

Working with Professionals

Engaging a knowledgeable real estate agent familiar with Tottenville can provide invaluable guidance. They can assist with pricing, marketing, and negotiations, ensuring a smoother transaction.

Understanding the Timeline

Buyers: From mortgage pre-approval to closing, the process can take several months.
Sellers: Preparing the home, listing, and closing also requires time and coordination.

FAQs

Is Tottenville a good place to invest in real estate?

Yes, Tottenville's unique charm and stable market make it an attractive option for investors seeking long-term value.

What types of homes are available in Tottenville?

The neighborhood offers a mix of historic homes, single-family houses, and modern constructions, catering to various preferences.

How is the commute from Tottenville to Manhattan?

The Staten Island Railway connects Tottenville to the St. George Ferry Terminal, providing access to Manhattan via the Staten Island Ferry.

Are there good schools in Tottenville?

Yes, Tottenville is home to reputable schools, including Tottenville High School, known for its academic programs.

What amenities does Tottenville offer?

Residents enjoy access to parks, waterfront views, shopping centers, and dining options, contributing to a high quality of life.

How can I determine the value of my Tottenville home?

Consulting with a local real estate agent and reviewing recent comparable sales can provide an accurate assessment of your home's value.

Whether you're buying or selling, understanding the nuances of Tottenville's real estate market in 2025 is essential. With its unique character, stable market, and community appeal, Tottenville continues to be a desirable neighborhood in Staten Island. Engaging with local professionals and staying informed will help you navigate the process successfully.

Multiple cash offers on your home in minutes with at least one at

100% of market value.

Call 718-608-4892 to receive your multiple cash offers today.

Your Home Sold Guaranteed or We'll Buy It!*